Several months ago I shared an article “The fall of the postural-structural-biomechanical model in manual and physical therapies; exemplified by lower back pain.” with about twenty of my colleague therapists and asked for their feedback and opinion. The reactions I received or the lack thereof actually surprised me.

For those of you who didn’t read the article in question, the text composed by Eyal Lederman questions, based on statistical analysis in regard to PSB factors and lower back pain, the validity of the often used and currently very popular postural-structural-biomechanical (PSB) model. According to Lederman the therapists applying the model falsely assume structural imbalances and asymmetries to be the cause of (lower back) pain. He thinks to prove this by sharing statistical research that fails to confirm a relationship between several postural-structural-biomechanical properties and (the occurrence of) lower back pain. While questioning the relationship between lower back pain and trunk asymmetries, low muscle strength, lumbar lordosis, disc degeneration, short (tight) hamstrings and psoas muscles he emphasizes the importance of what he refers to as the “biological reserve” (stress-resistance or adaptability as I prefer calling it).

To my surprise nearly all inquired colleagues – most of which look at their clients especially through a pair of PSB model glasses – regarded Lederman’s opinion simply as wrong or avoided discussing it all together. One often heard argument opposing Lederman’s ideas was, “I’ve applied the PSB model with success, which proves it does work therefore proving Lederman wrong.” Although understandable, this explanation doesn’t make much sense when thinking of the many influences (known and unknown) we exert during our treatment and exercise sessions and all that follows (known and unknown) in reaction to them. We can never say, beyond a doubt, what it is that makes our clients feel better. Unsettling as it might be, even the most knowledgeable therapists among us can merely make an educated guess, no more.

Only one colleague had the brightness of mind to imply that Lederman’s point of view was a righteous one. He argued that questioning the validity (or for that matter the existence) of one single, strongly distinct and fenced approach to all pain problems, and lower back pain in specific, was justified. There is after all far more to consider than only the postural-structural-biomechanical (postural, structural and biomechanical) variables of our clients suffering (lower back) pain. He concluded, “The PSB model is just a single approach to physical complaints, one of many.”

What struck me as odd is that of all inquired colleagues merely one thought to think of the complexity of (lower back) pain, all the possibly involved factors (known and unknown) and the possible solutions and/or remedies (known and unknown). Surely he could not be the only therapist realizing that no client is alike, pain comes in many different shapes and forms, is influenced by many internal and external factors and might therefore be approached from many different angles and eased in many different ways.

Although the reasons for the absence of an all encompassing answer from all my colleagues are likely manifold, I think I might have received more enlightening feedback if only Lederman would have reached a hand. Instead, he makes the same unfortunate mistake as those he tries to educate. By seemingly denying the possible use of the PSB model all together he displays a limited point of view equal to those who only work according to the very model he questions. I can’t help but think that his rather one-sided deliberation is probably not conducive to starting a useful discussion but instead shuts the door on exchanging thoughts. It would have been great if he’d have mentioned that, “although the PSB model might be effective at times – this despite the fact that certain statistics seem to prove otherwise – there is far more to consider, for example the biological reserve or stress-resistance of our clients”.

Be that as it may, I think the regrettable form in which Lederman shares his ideas does not excuse my colleagues from displaying an equally black and white train of thought – we should know better.

While I do not expect all of us to agree with every therapy philosophy, approach or technique I do feel we should at least acknowledge that there is more than we agree with, more than we know about, more than we (think we) understand and more than we are comfortable with. Just like stories, our clients and the pain they experience have many, many sides to them – as therapists maybe our thinking should be just as multifaceted.

© Willem Kramer for Willem Kramer, 2011. | Permalink | 2 comments | Add to del.icio.us digg
Who's linking ? Technorati BlogPulse Google
Want more on these topics ? Browse the archive of posts filed under Anatomy Links, My European Clinic, News.

The unique therapy we use at Veel Beter Fysiotherapie (transl. “Way Better Physical Therapy”) is exclusively developed for professional athletes.

Because of its intended clientele the therapy is solely aimed at results. Professional athletes are, after all, needed back in action as soon as possible and stronger than ever.

Now Veel Beter makes her unique approach and amazing results available to all her clients.

Because knowing what to treat and exercise is most important, we start with a thorough screening. With the support of an exceptional anatomy resource – developed by Willem Kramer, one of the co-owner of Veel Beter Fysiotherapie – we trace your pain or injury. All muscles, fasciae, nerves and other organs (body parts with a unique function) with a direct and indirect connection to your physical complaint(s) are examined and tested. The connecting organs found to have a negative influence over your pain or injury, are added to a so-called “To Treat list”.

In several treatment sessions, using unique hands-on treatment techniques and specific exercises, we switch the negative influences of the organs connecting with your pain or injury to positive. By turning the influences positive we clear out the road to recovery, allowing your body to heal in just days instead of weeks.

Because of our unique approach we might treat your hip after you sprain your ankle, your back when you suffer knee complaints or your abdominal region in case of neck pain. Your Veel Beter Therapist can explain and show you the intriguing inter-organ connections and influences.

© Willem Kramer for Willem Kramer, 2010. | Permalink | No comment | Add to del.icio.us digg
Who's linking ? Technorati BlogPulse Google
Want more on these topics ? Browse the archive of posts filed under My European Clinic, News.

Gijs, our interior designer, added new furniture and color (to say the least) to make our treatment center an even more comfortable hangout for our clients.

© Willem Kramer for Willem Kramer, 2009. | Permalink | No comment | Add to del.icio.us digg
Who's linking ? Technorati BlogPulse Google
Want more on these topics ? Browse the archive of posts filed under My European Clinic, News.

The PT center I own with two of my colleagues, is called “Veel Beter Fysiotherapie”. This seemingly pretentious name (Veel Beter means “Way Better” in Dutch) is not picked to brag about the quality of our work, but says something about how our clients feel after their treatment.  We hear the words “way better” from our clients so often (“It feels way better”) that we decided to make it the name of our clinic.

Veel Beter Physical Therapy is located in a 5,500 square feet, two story building, in a town called Almere. It has a lounge area, a gym, locker rooms, and eight large private treatment rooms. For all you world travelers out there, Almere is situated close to Amsterdam, the capital of the Netherlands.

Our clientele consists mainly of professional, amateur, and recreational athletes. The reason why athletes come to seek our help is because we specialize in treating acute soft tissue injuries. With our multifaceted treatment approach we are able to help most athletes return to action in less than a week.

We pride ourselves on creating a relaxed atmosphere. Not only the interior of our clinic is inviting and laidback, the therapists are also taught to behave casual and friendly, of course without sacrificing on quality and dedication.

© Willem Kramer for Willem Kramer, 2009. | Permalink | 2 comments | Add to del.icio.us digg
Who's linking ? Technorati BlogPulse Google
Want more on these topics ? Browse the archive of posts filed under My European Clinic, News.